1NC- you could be a little louder, but you were overall clear--so its fine. I did notice that you read the same card twice. Next time, try not to do that.
2AC- your analysis on case was very good! Your line by line on case was impressive and very responsive. You have a lot of ethos.
2NC- You should try not to only read cards! Do more analysis on the fiscal cliff DA!
1NR- Your analysis on the fiscal cliff DA was good, but please try to tell me a more coherent link story!
1AR- this speech was excellent. You did a great job persuading me that you don't link to the disad and that the negative can't access their impacts. The empirics that referred back to the Chinese economy was utilized well!
2NR- Your 2NR was only a minute long! Next time, be sure to use or at least try to use all your speech time.
2AR- your overview on case was very good!
RFD: I am persuaded that the negative can't access their nuclear war impacts. The 1A and 2A do a great job of explaining the no link argument made. The aff did a good job defending their aff and proving how HSR would ultimately boost the economy by creating jobs, increasing private sector investment and would decrease pollution.
Tips
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dennis--try to give more than a 1/2 minute 2NR! Develop your arguments!
Kent--please flow!
Speaker Point System
Edgemont
Kent Cai- 28
Jared Rosner- 28
Lakeland
Ryan Mulhern-27
Dennis San Lucas-26.5
No comments:
Post a Comment